The original definition was by implication homophobic; the term 'unnatural' has a long history in
legal and biblical commentary deriving from Romans 1-18-32, in which the
apostle Paul condemns non-procreative sexual acts. Of course, in 1899
male homosexual practice was illegal under UK law, but this was also the
case in 1933, when the
OED1 Supplement editors produced a much more neutral definition of the term
homosexual itself, included in the
OED for the first time at this date: 'pertaining to or characterised by propensity for one's own sex'. It is interesting that the
OED1 lexicographers did not supply more recent, post-17c, evidence of usage for
catamite, since they themselves used
catamite as a definitional term (for senses of
Ganymede,
hermaphrodite,
ingle,
and elsewhere) and it would not have been hard to find examples
elsewhere (e.g. in Robinson Ellis's commentary on Catullus, published in
1876).
[1]Given that the editor of the 20th-century Supplement to
OED,
R. W. Burchfield, took a special interest in updating the treatment of
sexual vocabulary, we might have expected him to have revised the entry and removed the condemnatory term 'unnatural' -
especially since he too used
catamite in some of the definitions he added to the Dictionary (e.g. for
jocker, 'a tramp who is accompanied by a youth who begs for him or who acts as his catamite'). But he left the
OED1 entry as it was, neither re-writing the definition nor adding more recent quotations of its use.
[2] Burchfield was no lexicographical homophobe: he was the first to include the sexual sense of
lesbian and related words in the
OED, and he carefully rewrote the entry for
homosexual (adj.) which had only been added to the Dictionary in 1933 (he re-phrased the definition and supplied further quotations, also adding definitions and quotations for the nouns
homosexual and
homosexualist). However he was inconsistent in his updating. Not only did he leave the term 'unnatural' in the entry for
catamite untouched, but he also passed over
OED1's definition of
ingle (sense
1) as 'A boy-favourite (in bad sense); a catamite', though he certainly
considered the entry since he added two quotations to it - from T. E.
Lawrence (1926) and H. Nicolson (1962). Similarly, Burchfield let stand
OED1's definitions of
Sapphism as 'unnatural sexual relations between women, and
tribade as 'a woman who practises unnatural vice with other women', while adding
sapphist and
sapphistically to the Dictionary along with accompanying 20c quotations.
These
editorial decisions tell us both about Burchfield and about the culture
of the time; they indicate that different sorts of homosexuality,
whether male or female, continued to be problematic, in varying ways,
into the 1970s and 1980s. Like the original
OED1 definitions,
Burchfield's treatment of sexual terms constitutes lexicographical
evidence for these attitudes - as does also the decision of the
OED2 editors, in their merging of
OED1 and the Supplement in 1989, to rewrite the definitions for
Sapphism and
tribade, dropping the references to 'unnatural' and 'vice' (though the term 'vice' lives on in the etymology of
Sapphism even today, i.e. December 2011).
OED2's 1989 tolerance of the
OED1 definition for
catamite,
with its reference to 'unnatural purposes', is likewise an important
piece of historical evidence. And so is the recent decision, apparently
part of the
OED2 re-launch, to re-write the definition and re-date the last quotation from 1795 to 1822 (see discussion on previous page
here). That is why it is imperative that the lexicographers should date the
change clearly, alerting users to its much more recent provenance.
Finally, it should be noted that
OED Online has been inconsistent in this unlabelled partial updating. The Dictionary continues to contain other definitions and editorial material
indicative of cultural attitudes to sexuality or other matters which are
today unacceptable - as in the entry for
ingle, quoted above. And 1822 is certainly not an accurate indication of last use of
catamite:
google is a ready source for one of the most famous recent instances of
the word, the opening sentence of Anthony Burgess's 1980 novel
Earthly Powers:
'It was the afternoon of my eighty-first birthday, and I was in bed
with my catamite when Ali announced that the archbishop had come to see
me'.
Footnotes [1] Ellis 1876: 76. Ellis
was a close friend of James Murray, the chief editor of
OED1; see
Murray
1977: 324-5;
Brewer 2007b: 175.
[2] For Burchfield's interest in sexual vocabulary see
Burchfield 1972 and
Brewer 2007b: 181-2, 203-5.
catamite was used by Aldous Huxley, a writer intensively quoted by Burchfield in the Supplement.